Debt Finances & Money Home

Changing Gears on Our Debt Repayment

For the last 3 years, we’ve been on a mission to pay off our non-home debt. In that time, we’ve paid off about $82,000! You can track our current status in the debt scales in the sidebar.

But now we’ve decided to switch from paying down our car and school debt to paying down our second mortgage.

If you recall, we financed our home purchase with two loans. Since we didn’t have nearly enough for a down payment (even 5%), we got two loans. The first, for about $311,000, was 80% of the total price of the house, while the remaining 20% was about $78,000.

The Loans in More Detail

So not only did we finance 100%, but we also got a 5-year, interest-only mortgage for loan #1 (the big one). That means by late 2009, we’ll need to either sell the house, refinance the loan(s) or just let the rate reset to the current market rates.

Yeah, we were dumb and couldn’t afford what we bought at the time. But we lucked out and we can now easily afford the mortgages. Whew!

The makeup of the loans are as follows:

Loan 1: 5/1 Interest-Only Arm, $311,000, 5.250%

Loan 2: 15 year balloon loan (amortized over 30 yrs), $78,000, 7.875%

Why Change Our Plans?

Compared to our starting point on non-home debt of $112,000, we’re so close to being rid of it all with just $30,000 left to pay off. So why not finish what we started?

Well, we’ve recently found out how much home prices have fallen based on talking to our neighbors and looking at home sale reports for the area. In another year, in order to refinance both of our loans together (to reduce the interest rate on the 20% loan), we would need our home appraised at $470,000. That’s the 20% equity above the total loan amount that the bank needs to finance the full loan.

At the last appraisal, our home was valued at $470k. Unfortunately, that was about 3.5 years ago, before everything went down the drain. Right now, based on research, I expect it would be appraised at $420,000. Granted, it might not sell for that, or it might, but we would need to give concessions at the closing table, but I’m confident it’s still there.

So with that assumption (and hope), to get our loan fully-financed, we would need to get our total loans from $389,000 down to $336,000. Wow. That’s a $53,000 reduction in the loans.

Our New Debt Repayment Plan

So since our second mortgage is the higher interest rate of the two loans, and of all our debt, even after the tax deduction for interest paid, our plan is to pay down the 2nd mortgage first. I doubt we can pay down the full $53,000 in the next 14 months, but we can get a good chunk of that out of the way. The other hope is that real estate values start increasing by that time and a new appraisal would come in closer to $440,000.

If all else fails and we can’t get both loans refinanced together, then we’ll just refinance the first loan (the one that is resetting) and continue to pay down the second loan. It just doesn’t make sense to skip the mortgage debt that has the highest overall interest rate simply because it’s “good debt” as some people say.

Debt is debt, even if it’s supposedly an appreciable asset (that is currently depreciating) that has tax benefits. If you’re paying more interest on it (even after taxes) than your other debt, then you need to pay it off first.

For us, though, it’s been easier to pay down the smaller $10,000-$30,000 debts because an almost $80,000 loan seems just too overwhelming to handle in comparison. But as I said, debt is debt and we need to make the logical decision right now, not the emotional one.

About the author

Clever Dude


  • Excellent decision! Good debt, bad debt… with the economy the way it is, it feels like any debt is bad debt. Tax write off or not, it’s costing you money and it needs to go. My husband and I are in a similar situation. Only difference is, we are dealing with a second mortgage on a home we couldn’t sell after we purchased the home we’re currently living in. Yeah. Two homes, three mortgages, and falling home values make for a big mess! We are attacking the second mortgage on our rental because we are upside down on that house and we have a refinance coming up in 2010 (plus we are losing money on that thing every month). We also live in the DC Metro area, but on the VA side. Hopefully the housing prices will pick up in a year or two, but I think our best bet is to hunker down and pay off these home loans. I know I’ll sleep better at night!

  • Here Here! Mr Chiots and I are currently focused on paying down our mortgage before our car loans because the interest rate is higher and we would save more in the long run. We are fortunate that we bought a cheap house in an area that has a slow steady increase in real estate values. We have lived here for 6 years and trying to have it paid off in 3 years, which is also when the cars will be paid off as well. We decided to hit the house first for security reasons. If we pay it off, we won’t have a mortgage payment each month, we’ll be able to save that money for retirement, house fix-ups, etc. Since we’re self-employed, not having to make a huge mortgage payment would be such peace of mind if business isn’t going well for the month!

    Kudos to you guys for admitting your financial follies and trying to make a change – too many people throw up their hands or just stick their heads in the sand and don’t admit it or do anything about it!

    PS- I’m so glad I don’t live in DC! We bought a small 2 bedroom home, with a 3 car garage and an unfinished upstairs (that will someday be 2 bedrooms and a bathroom) for $108,000, and it’s in a private gated lake community, we are surrounded by woods on 3 sides. I couldn’t bring myself to spend what you guys did on a house – I suppose that’s why I live in rural Ohio, and not somewhere else!

Leave a Comment