9 Compact Cars Mechanics Recommend Avoiding in 2025

January 24, 2025

Compact cars are known for being affordable and fuel-efficient. However, not every make and model will live up to those expectations. Unfortunately, some of them come with significant problems that can turn into expensive repairs. As a former mechanic, there are some smaller vehicles I’d steer clear of due to issues with reliability, costs, or poor build quality. That said, here is a look at nine cars I’d probably tell you to avoid.

1. Mitsubishi Mirage

The Mitsubishi Mirage continues to disappoint mechanics due to its underpowered engine and lackluster build quality. Its three-cylinder engine struggles to provide enough power, especially during highway driving, leading to a less-than-smooth ride. The interior materials feel cheap, and the technology features lag behind competitors. Mechanics often cite frequent transmission issues as a major drawback, which can result in expensive repairs.

2. Nissan Versa

Although the Nissan Versa is budget-friendly, mechanics often advise against it due to recurring issues with its continuously variable transmission (CVT). And honestly, I’d recommend against anything with a CVT. This is because CVTs are prone to overheating and premature failure, which can lead to costly repairs. The car’s thin insulation also results in excessive road noise, making it less comfortable for long drives. On top of all of that, the crash-test ratings are lower compared to other compact cars, raising safety concerns.

3. Chevrolet Spark

Mechanics are quick to point out the Chevrolet Spark’s shortcomings, starting with its cramped interior and weak engine. The 1.4-liter engine struggles to keep up, especially on inclines or when carrying passengers. Frequent complaints about electrical system failures and poor-quality components are common too. The Spark’s minimal safety features leave drivers and passengers vulnerable, and its poor crash-test ratings further diminish its appeal. Additionally, the lack of advanced tech features makes it feel outdated in 2025’s competitive market.

4. Ford EcoSport

Though marketed as a compact crossover, the Ford EcoSport falls into the compact car category due to its size—and it’s one mechanics recommend avoiding. The EcoSport’s underpowered engines and sluggish acceleration make it frustrating to drive. Its outdated design and lack of modern features fail to justify its price tag. Mechanics frequently encounter problems with its suspension system, leading to expensive repairs down the line.

5. Fiat 500X

You’ll see the Fiat on several of my “cars to avoid” lists. It’s just a bad car. The Fiat 500X may have stylish looks, but its reliability leaves much to be desired. Mechanics report frequent issues with its transmission and electrical systems, which can quickly become expensive to fix. The car’s cramped interior and small cargo space also make it less practical than other compact cars. Its fuel economy is subpar, especially considering its small size.

6. Volkswagen Jetta

While I typically like Volkswagen (and used to work on many myself), newer Jettas are often flagged by mechanics for reliability concerns. The 2025 Jetta suffers from ongoing issues with its turbocharged engine, which can lead to costly repairs. Electrical system failures, particularly with the infotainment and climate controls, are common complaints. The Jetta’s automatic transmission is also prone to jerking and premature wear.

7. Hyundai Accent

The Hyundai Accent may look appealing at first glance, but mechanics often highlight its weak engine and cheap build quality. Its lack of power becomes evident during highway driving, making it less versatile for everyday use. The interior materials feel low-grade, and the ride quality suffers on uneven roads. The Accent also tends to experience suspension problems, which can add up in repair costs over time.

8. Kia Rio

Despite its affordability, the Kia Rio struggles with long-term reliability, making it a car mechanics advise avoiding. Its engine and transmission systems are prone to wear and tear faster than competitors. The Rio’s safety features are minimal, leaving drivers and passengers at risk in the event of a collision. Interior quality is another weak point, with cheap materials that don’t age well.

9. Subaru Impreza

The Subaru Impreza, despite its reputation for all-wheel drive, has its share of issues that mechanics flag. Its CVT is a common point of failure, leading to expensive repair bills. The Impreza’s fuel economy is lower than expected for a compact car, making it less efficient than its rivals. Mechanics also report frequent complaints about the Impreza’s brake system and overall durability. While its all-wheel-drive system is a selling point, the car’s reliability problems outweigh this advantage.

Think Long-Term Before You Buy

When you are buying any car, it is important to look beyond the price tag or the initial appeal. You should do research. Check out what previous and current owners have to say about the vehicle. I’d also suggest checking out forums like Reddit where mechanics frequently discuss common issues. This can help you weed out a potential bad buy and save you a lot of heartache (and money).

Drew Blankenship

Drew Blankenship is a former Porsche technician who writes and develops content full-time. He lives in North Carolina, where he enjoys spending time with his wife and two children. While Drew no longer gets his hands dirty modifying Porsches, he still loves motorsport and avidly watches Formula 1.